So with word that this will be Matt Smith's last season, that Rose (Billie Piper) and David Tennant are coming back for the 50th season (not a spoiler, that is old news), what is up with the story line for this season's Doctor Who...
One may consider Russell T. Davies the best writer of all times (and he is), but let's give credit to Steven Moffat...a few years after Davies departure and his storylines are just as complex and compelling.
So, that begs the question to be ask...what's up with this season?
Or, before we go that far (since this is a show about time travel), were Amy and Rory actually sent back in the same time and place as Manhattan in the 1930s? Yes? Are you SURE? Think about it. Amy and Rory jumped off the roof of Winter's Quay to save themselves - and what did River Song say? That would create a paradox, and it would be as if the place never existed. So, how could the angel have sent Rory and Amy back to the same time and place - it was disappearing from history prior to the Doctor and River Song being (teleported?)
Listen to what Amy wrote the Doctor in her Afterword (link below) - there is not a reference made to confirm they went back to the same time and place. And what does she mean..."...you won't be coming back here for a while..."?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dajGPLWj_tw
Still think I am wrong...then why were there no years placed on their gravestone?? Eh, got you on that one.
No comments:
Post a Comment